Are you in compliance?

Don't miss out! Sign up today for our weekly newsletters and stay abreast of important GRC-related information and news.

Get updates on Compliance Week offerings, including new features, databases, research, and other resources, along with announcements of upcoming Webcasts, conferences, seminars, CPE/CLE opportunities and more.

Published every Thursday, Compliance Week Europe offers a condensed summary of risk, audit, and compliance news either originating in Europe, or of special interest to European compliance professionals. This newsletter will follow developments by the European Commission, as well as those of national governments across the region, or any U.S.-based news that might have consequence across the Atlantic. Frequency: weekly; Thursday a.m.

A fresh edition of Compliance Week delivered via e-mail and online every Tuesday morning, relentlessly focused on the disclosure, reporting and compliance requirements of our 25,000+ paying subscribers.

Published every Friday, Compliance Weekend was launched at the behest of subscribers, and offers a quick Plain English review of the week's key developments. We hope you enjoy this supplement to Compliance Week's Tuesday edition.


Status message

Start your free, no obligation 10-day trial to continue exploring with full access.

Courts Raise Specter Of ‘Collective’ Scienter

Martinek Paul J. | September 19, 2006

In a potentially ominous development for corporations, a handful of decisions by federal judges in New York have strayed from the traditional rule that a company can’t be found to have had fraudulent intent—known in the law as scienter—unless the individual making a false or misleading material statement actually had such an intent.

Under a new theory of “collective scienter,” fraudulent intent can be imputed to the corporation by aggregating the intent of employees who had nothing to do with a false corporate statement. At its most extreme, the knowledge of a janitor who came across a discarded document in the trash in a remote office could be the basis of finding that a corporation knew a statement was false.

The theory has been flatly rejected by two federal circuit courts: the 5th Circuit in New Orleans and the 9th Circuit in San Francisco. But the 6th Circuit in Cincinnati “seemed to apply the collective scienter theory” in a... To get the full story, subscribe now.