Expert: SEC’s view on Prager Metis indemnity clauses ‘problematic’
By 
Adrianne Appel2023-10-18T17:00:00
Audit firms should carefully weigh the pros and cons of indemnity clauses in light of the Securities and Exchange Commission’s (SEC) recent complaint against Prager Metis.
Last month, the SEC charged Prager Metis with violating independence requirements of federal securities laws on 62 audits, 11 examinations, and 144 reviews, largely because the firm included indemnification provisions in 87 client engagement letters. The agency’s complaint, filed in U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida, is just the latest example of its enforcement focus on auditor independence.
The prudent path for auditors is not to use indemnity clauses in any way whatsoever, said Frank Borger Gilligan, a member of the corporate, mergers and acquisitions, and securities practice group at law firm Dickinson Wright.
Related articles
-
PremiumAuditor independence on regulators’ radars
The Public Company Accounting Oversight Board and Securities and Exchange Commission have emphasized in public statements auditor independence is a critical enforcement area, prompting the need for firms to reacquaint themselves with each agency’s requirements.
-
News BriefSEC accuses Prager Metis of hundreds of auditor independence violations
Accounting firm Prager Metis violated auditor independence rules through use of indemnification provisions in its engagement letters hundreds of times during a period of nearly three years, the Securities and Exchange Commission charged in a lawsuit.
-
News BriefSEC chief accountant eyeing auditor use of network member firms
The Securities and Exchange Commission is paying added scrutiny toward audit firms’ increasing use of network affiliates in their work and the potential for inconsistent quality that comes with such an approach.
More from Accounting & Auditing
-
ArticlePCAOB’s Christina Ho: How emerging technologies could improve audit quality
Emerging technologies, like artificial intelligence (AI) and advanced data analytics, can improve audit quality in significant ways. As the regulatory overseer of public-company audits, the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) has a critical role to play by ensuring that its audit standards evolve as the audit profession evolves.
-
News BriefPCAOB chair Williams latest independent official pushed out by Trump
Continuing a Trump administration practice of firing independent regulators, the head of the Public Accounting Oversight Board has been sent packing.
-
News BriefPhoto gallery: Compliance Week Third-Party Risk Management Summit
Nearly 200 attendees gathered at the Hotel Zaza in Austin, Texas for Compliance Week’s 2025 June 3-4. This year’s conference brought together compliance professionals from across the globe to discuss how rapidly shifting politics, policies and supply chain realities are affecting their jobs, and share best practices to respond.