Proxy advisory firms have provided valuable advice to companies and shareholders sorting through the deal mania of recent years—right until deal mania swept up the proxy firms themselves.

In the last six weeks, Institutional Shareholder Services dropped its venerable name in favor of RiskMetrics, the company that purchased ISS one year ago. Its chief rival, Glass, Lewis & Co., was sold to the Ontario Teachers Pension Plan, capping a tumultuous 10 months of ownership by a Chinese media group. And on Sept. 19 RiskMetrics filed documents for a possible initial public offering, which has some wondering how a publicly traded advisory firm can do its job independently.