Virtue may be its own rewardโbut just to be safe, shareholders of Nortel Networks squeezed it into a $2.5 billion lawsuit settlement anyway. When Nortel announced last month that it agreed to pay nearly $2.5 billion in cash and stock to resolve investor claims stemming from three years of restated financial results in the early […]
Regulatory Enforcement
New EU Opinion Clouds Whistleblowing Plans
In what could become a major headache for U.S. companies doing business overseas, a European advisory body says whistleblower systems and codes of conduct should be tailored to comply with each European nationโs data privacy laws. The pronouncement comes from the European Unionโs Data Protection Working Party, and stems from a similar move by French […]
Promises Broken, Shareholders Sue Murdoch
Playing with poison can be a dangerous thing. So, it seems, can be playing with a companyโs promises to shareholders. News Corp. has suffered a winter of discontent with its shareholders, as the two sides argued in court about whether the company could renege on a 2004 promise not to adopt a poison pill. Rupert […]
Bad Controls Put Company On SEC Hot Seat
In what is believed to be the first case of its kind, an Indiana manufacturer settled charges with the Securities and Exchange Commission earlier this month that poor internal controls led to five years of sloppy accounting and a restatement that nicked company financial reports by $16 million. The Feb. 9 settlement with Cummins Inc., […]
Suit Against PCAOB Aims To Clock SOX
The Sarbanes-Oxley Act has long wrapped up executives in a cloak of frustration. Now a high-powered legal challenge to the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board wants to unravel the whole thing. At issue is the very constitutionality of the PCAOB, and whether it wields so much influence over public commerce that its members should be […]
DoJ Bait & Switch Probe Tactic Under Fire
The Securities and Exchange Commission may need to reconsider how it coordinates investigations with the Department of Justice in light of a recent decision by a federal judge throwing out criminal securities fraud charges due to the too-cozy relationship between the SEC and DOJ. Judge Ancer Haggerty of the U.S. District Court in Oregon wrote […]
Delaware Ruling Questions Established Merger Procedures
A recent Delaware Chancery Court decision raises questions about several well-established merger transaction procedures that prior court rulings had viewed favorably. In the case, In re TeleCommunications Inc. Shareholders Litigation, the court allowed a challenge to a 1998 merger between TCI and an AT&T subsidiary to go to trial, citing โgenuine issuesโ about whether the […]
High Court Ponders State-Level Class Action On Securities
Securities law streaked across the stage of the U.S. Supreme Court earlier this month, as lawyers argued in front of the justices about whether certain state securities-fraud class action suits are still valid despite a 1998 federal law intended to curb such disputes at the state level. The case, Merrill Lynch v. Dabit, is the […]
Overseas, A Change In Tune For Whistleblowers
A federal appeals court has sounded the first sour note for overseas employees who blow the whistle on corporate fraud: The Sarbanes-Oxley Act does not protect them from retaliation. Earlier this month, the 1st Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that a citizen of Argentina who worked for a subsidiary of U.S.-based Boston Scientific Corp. could […]
Cases Highlight Dangers In D&O Insurance Gaps
T hree recent federal court decisions have sent a sharp reminder that corporate directors and officers must all hang together figurativelyโor insurers might force them to all hang together legally. In all three cases, one personโs false statement invalidated director and officer insurance protecting everyone else on the board. The decisions underscore the need for […]


