SEC commissioner: ESG standards attempt to ‘measure the unmeasurable’
By 
Aaron Nicodemus2023-05-02T20:34:00
At a speech before a European financial services think tank, a Republican commissioner with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) threw cold water on regulators’ attempts to create environmental, social, and governance (ESG) standards for public companies.
Speaking Friday in Sweden before EuroFi, Hester Peirce argued materiality-based standards—not ESG standards—best suit investors’ needs.
Peirce said ESG-specific standards “cannot help but direct the allocation of private capital, especially when they are combined with sustainable finance initiatives designed to encourage financing of favored activities and the defunding of disfavored activities.” This redirection of capital is not, she argued, meant to primarily serve investors’ needs “but rather to direct the allocation of private capital to further government ends.”
Related articles
-
News Brief
SEC adopts revised fund name requirements
The Securities and Exchange Commission adopted amendments to its rule covering fund names to ensure the regulation is appropriate to address new investment drivers, namely environmental, social, and governance matters.
-
PremiumSEC’s Gensler mum on timing of climate rule, says ‘important issues’ around Scope 3 requirements
Gary Gensler, despite being put on the spot by a member of Congress, declined to provide an update on when the Securities and Exchange Commission might approve its climate-related disclosure rule for public companies.
-
News BriefTreasury report recommends stricter supervision of insurers’ climate risks
The Treasury Department’s Federal Insurance Office issued a report on gaps in how states supervise and assess climate-related risks among insurers.
More from Regulatory Policy
-
ArticleCalifornia climate rules cause uncertainty as CARB delays draft guidance
California has delayed the release of draft greenhouse gas reporting rules for businesses until early 2026, the California Air Resources Board said.
-
PremiumNew EU Data Act may impact companies’ GDPR compliance efforts
New rules that have recently come into effect across the EU will allow for greater transfers of data between companies, though experts fear the changes could conflict with Europe’s strict privacy legislation, which protects personal information.
-
ArticleNine states collaborating on data privacy enforcement across state lines
Nine states are collaborating to write and enforce comprehensive data privacy laws, in an effort to protect consumers across jurisdictions and due to the absence of a broad, federal privacy law.